Review Form

Questions

Yes

Partially

No

Is the title of the study appropriate?

Does the abstract summarize the article clearly?

Does the introduction provide important issues in the field?

Is the purpose of the study stated clearly?

Does the study review adequate literature?

Does the study provide sound research methods, and logical presentation with good validity and reliability?

Is the methodology consistent with the practice?

Are the results/findings innovative, which contribute to the field?

Is the presentation of the findings adequate and consistent?

Are the tables, figures, or charts arranged appropriately?

Does the discussion compare the results of the current study to previous studies presented in the literature?

Are the conclusions and generalizations based on the findings?

Are the recommendations/suggestions meaningful, and based on the findings?

Do the references provide enough information in APA?

Is the language understandable and clear?

Does the article have cohesion throughout the writing?

Sections of the manuscript

Comments

Title

Abstract

Introduction

Literature review

Methodology

Results/findings

Discussion

Conclusion & suggestions

References & citations

Language

Other issues